Article

Intellectual Disability at Work: Your ADA Rights

Can an employer ask about special education, refuse a job coach, or fire you over assumptions about an intellectual disability? How the ADA protects applicants and workers.

9 min read

An Intellectual Disability Is Covered by the ADA

Title I of the Americans with Disabilities Act applies to private employers with 15 or more employees for 20 or more weeks in the current or preceding calendar year and to state and local government employers; federal workers are covered through the Rehabilitation Act, and many state laws reach smaller employers. The EEOC's regulation at 29 CFR 1630.2 lists an intellectual disability as a mental impairment and says it should easily be concluded that an intellectual disability substantially limits brain function. The EEOC also points to limits in learning, reading, and thinking. A person who was misclassified as having an intellectual disability in the past is covered under the record-of-disability definition, and a person who is refused a job, fired, or treated worse because an employer believes they have an intellectual disability can be covered as regarded as having a disability. Coverage only under the regarded-as definition does not entitle a worker to accommodation.

Questions About Special Education Are Off Limits Before a Job Offer

Before a conditional job offer, an employer may not ask whether you have an intellectual disability or require a medical exam. The EEOC gives examples of questions an employer cannot ask an applicant: whether they took classes designated for special education or special needs students, and whether school records show an intellectual disability. An employer may ask about job abilities, such as whether you can read, put files in alphabetical order, or place items in numerical order. If your disability is obvious or you disclose it, and the employer reasonably believes it may interfere with a job-related function, it may ask you to describe or demonstrate how you would perform that function, with or without accommodation. If your disability is obvious or disclosed and the employer reasonably believes you will need an accommodation, it may ask whether you will need one and what type. In one EEOC example, an office clerk applicant who said she sometimes needs reminders of her duties could be asked whether she needs an accommodation such as a detailed checklist, but not whether she will need frequent leave or whether her condition is genetic. The same limits apply to questions put to a job coach, family member, or social worker who comes to an interview with you.

Genetic Questions Raise a Separate GINA Problem

Some intellectual disabilities have genetic causes, such as Down syndrome or fragile X syndrome. The Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act generally bars employers from requesting, requiring, or purchasing genetic information about an applicant or employee, including family medical history, under 29 CFR 1635.8. The EEOC notes that asking whether an intellectual disability is genetic can violate GINA, and that employers asking for accommodation documentation may want to tell the worker and their health care provider not to supply genetic information.

After an Offer, the Employer Must Look at You, Not Your Diagnosis

After a conditional offer, an employer may ask health questions or require an exam if it does so for everyone entering the same job category. If you disclose an intellectual disability at this stage, it may ask about the extent of the disability and may ask for documentation from an appropriate professional answering questions designed to assess whether you can do the job safely. It may not withdraw the offer if you can perform the essential functions of the job, with or without reasonable accommodation, without posing a direct threat. In one EEOC example, a deli clerk with five years of injury-free experience disclosed an intellectual disability on a post-offer questionnaire, and the new employer worried about her using a meat slicer; because there was no evidence she posed a significant risk of substantial harm, the employer could not withdraw the offer.

Medical Questions During Employment and Performance Problems

Once you are working, an employer generally may ask disability-related questions or require an exam only when it has a reasonable belief, based on objective evidence, that a medical condition is affecting your ability to do the job or that you pose a direct threat. It may also ask for information needed to support an accommodation request, to verify sick leave under a doctor-note rule that applies to everyone, or as part of a voluntary wellness program. Poor performance is often unrelated to a disability. In one EEOC example, a mailroom clerk with an intellectual disability who had performed well for five years began misdirecting mail after moving into his brother's house; his supervisor could ask why his performance had declined and look for ways to prevent mistakes, but could not question him about his intellectual disability without objective evidence connecting it to the problem.

Your Disability and Accommodation Stay Confidential

Medical information must be kept confidential and stored separately from ordinary personnel files. An employer may share it with supervisors who need to know about work restrictions or accommodations, with first aid and safety staff if you might need emergency help, with government officials investigating compliance, and where needed for workers' compensation or insurance claims. The EEOC says an employer should not tell curious coworkers that you are receiving an accommodation, such as extra time to finish training, because that effectively discloses that you have a disability.

Accommodations to Apply and Interview

The ADA's definition of reasonable accommodation in 42 U.S.C. Section 12111 includes adjustments to examinations and training materials and qualified readers. The EEOC lists application accommodations such as someone to read or explain application materials, demonstrating what the job requires instead of only describing it, modified tests or manuals, and replacing a written test with an expanded interview in which you show your skills at the workplace or employment office. In one EEOC example, a baker applicant with an intellectual disability and a speech and hearing impairment could be accommodated with an expanded interview to demonstrate that he could do the job. Telling a store manager that you need someone to help you with the application is itself a request for accommodation.

Common Accommodations on the Job

Not every worker with an intellectual disability needs an accommodation, and the EEOC says most accommodations cost little or nothing. Examples from EEOC guidance include giving instructions at a slower pace, allowing more time to finish training, breaking tasks into sequential steps, using charts, pictures, or color-coding, detailed written or recorded task schedules, extra training, and allowing a third party to attend training. A job coach can help you learn the job, provide monitoring and support, and help you and your employer work out what accommodation is needed. Other examples include a modified schedule for counseling appointments, bringing someone to a job evaluation or disciplinary meeting to help you ask questions and understand what is happening, equipment such as a telephone with clearly labeled speed-dial buttons, moving your workstation to a quieter area, and swapping a marginal task you cannot do, such as counting the cash drawer at closing, for one a coworker usually handles. If you can no longer do your job even with accommodation, reassignment to a vacant position you are qualified for may be required. The duty is ongoing, so you may need more than one accommodation over time.

Asking for an Accommodation, Including Through a Family Member

There are no magic words. You only need to tell your employer that you need a change at work because of your disability, and the request can come from a family member, friend, health professional, or other representative. In one EEOC example, a mother who contacted her son's supervisor to discuss problems he was having at work and possible solutions made an accommodation request. The EEOC also says an employer must start the conversation itself when it knows you have a disability, knows or has reason to know you are having problems at work because of it, and knows or has reason to know the disability prevents you from asking. In one EEOC example, a flower shop knew about a worker's disability, suspected it was why he kept misplacing flowers and containers, and knew he could not ask for an accommodation because of it; the employer raised the issue and, when he agreed it would help, labeled the containers and refrigerator shelves.

What Documentation an Employer Can Require

When a disability or the need for accommodation is not obvious, an employer may ask for reasonable documentation showing that you have an intellectual disability and why the accommodation is needed. It is not entitled to your entire medical record. If the disability is obvious, the focus should be on your limitations rather than on proving the diagnosis, and the EEOC notes that information about functional limitations can also come from you, your family, and friends, not only from professionals. If you have more than one condition, the employer may ask only about the one that requires accommodation.

What an Employer Does Not Have to Provide

Under 29 CFR 1630.9 and the definition in 1630.2(p), an employer does not have to provide an accommodation that would cause undue hardship, meaning significant difficulty or expense. It does not have to remove an essential function of the job, accept performance below its standards, or excuse violations of conduct rules that are job-related, consistent with business necessity, and applied to everyone. If more than one accommodation would work, your preference should get primary consideration, but the employer may choose an easier or less expensive option that is effective. In one EEOC example, a clerk who asked to have written memos recorded could instead have someone read and explain them, because both worked.

Safety Concerns and Stereotypes

An employer may refuse to hire or may fire someone for safety reasons only if the person poses a direct threat, which the EEOC's regulation defines as a significant risk of substantial harm to themselves or others that cannot be eliminated or reduced by reasonable accommodation. That decision must rest on objective, factual evidence about your present ability, considering how long the risk lasts, how severe and how likely the harm is, and how soon it could happen. The EEOC warns against acting on myths, fears, or stereotypes. In one example, a restaurant could not refuse a kitchen job based on the assumption that people with intellectual disabilities cannot safely use knives or work near hot ovens; it had to consider information from a professional and the applicant, along with prior training, work experience, and safety history. By contrast, an employer may deny a job around dangerous machinery to someone whose disability makes it impossible to understand and follow the safety procedures.

Harassment, Retaliation, and Interference

The ADA prohibits disability-based harassment, including slurs, mockery, ridicule, insults, threats, and interference with your work, when it is frequent or severe enough to create a hostile work environment or leads to a firing, demotion, or other adverse action. Isolated minor comments usually do not meet that standard, but a pattern can, and an employer that learns of harassment should investigate and act promptly. Under 42 U.S.C. Section 12203, an employer may not retaliate against you for opposing disability discrimination, filing a charge, or testifying, assisting, or participating in an investigation, proceeding, or hearing, and it may not coerce, intimidate, threaten, or interfere with you for exercising or helping others exercise ADA rights. The EEOC also says it is unlawful to retaliate against someone for requesting a reasonable accommodation.

Deadlines, Records, and Help From Someone You Trust

A charge with the EEOC generally must be filed within 180 days of the discriminatory act, extended to 300 days where a state or local agency enforces a law prohibiting disability discrimination; federal employees generally must contact an agency EEO counselor within 45 days. The EEOC says a family member, social worker, or other representative may file a charge on behalf of someone else. Each refusal to hire, denied accommodation, or firing can carry its own deadline. Keep copies of accommodation requests and responses, job postings, applications and offer letters, any questionnaires about school or medical history, performance reviews before and after you disclosed your disability, disciplinary notices, and messages from coworkers or supervisors about your disability.

When to Get a Free Consult

Consider a free consult if you were asked about special education or school records before a job offer, had an offer withdrawn after disclosing an intellectual disability, were refused a job coach, extra training, or simpler instructions, were disciplined without the help you asked for, were kept out of a job because of safety assumptions, were harassed about your disability, or were punished after you or a family member asked for an accommodation. An employment lawyer can review whether the ADA, the Rehabilitation Act, GINA, or a state law applies to your situation and whether your filing deadline is approaching. No fee unless we win.

Primary Sources

Think You Have a Case?

This article is general information, not legal advice. For a review of your situation, get a free consult with the YesLawyer team.

Get Your Free Consult

Related Resources