Workplace Rights2 min read

Fired or Not Hired Over an Arrest With No Conviction: EEOC Arrest Record Rules and Your Rights

Published
Worker reading an employment decision letter at a desk after a background check: Fired Over an Arrest, No Conviction?

At a glance

Fired or Not Hired Over an Arrest With No Conviction: EEOC Arrest Record Rules and Your Rights: key takeaways

A visual summary of this post's main points. Read the article for context and limits.

  • Key point 1

    An arrest is not proof that a person did anything wrong, and the EEOC says an employer should not treat an arrest alone as proof of misconduct

  • Key point 2

    Using arrest records can violate Title VII when it has an unjustified, disproportionate effect on workers of a particular race or national origin

  • Key point 3

    An employer may look at the conduct behind an arrest if it is relevant to the job, but it must be able to show a real basis for its decision

You were arrested, the charges were dropped or never filed, and your employer still let you go or pulled a job offer. It can feel like being punished for something that was never proven. Federal guidance treats an arrest very differently from a conviction, and that difference can matter to your rights.

In this article
  1. Why an Arrest Is Not the Same as a Conviction
  2. How Arrest Records Can Violate Title VII
  3. What an Employer May Look At
  4. Background Check Reports and the Seven-Year Rule
  5. State and Local Rules Can Go Further
  6. What To Save
  7. Raise It and Watch the Deadline
  8. Free Case Review

Key takeaways

  • An arrest is not proof that a person did anything wrong, and the EEOC says an employer should not treat an arrest alone as proof of misconduct

  • Using arrest records can violate Title VII when it has an unjustified, disproportionate effect on workers of a particular race or national origin

  • An employer may look at the conduct behind an arrest if it is relevant to the job, but it must be able to show a real basis for its decision

  • Federal law generally bars background check companies from reporting arrests that are more than seven years old, with a salary exception

  • Many states and cities add their own limits on arrest questions, so the rules where you work matter

  • An EEOC charge generally must be filed within 180 days, extended to 300 days in many states, so do not wait

Why an Arrest Is Not the Same as a Conviction

The EEOC's enforcement guidance on arrest and conviction records explains that an arrest does not establish that a person committed a crime. People are arrested and released, charged and cleared, or have charges dismissed. For that reason the guidance says an employer should not rely on the arrest record alone as proof of misconduct. A conviction is different, because it is generally treated as reliable evidence that the conduct occurred.

How Arrest Records Can Violate Title VII

Title VII does not ban every background check. The concern is that arrest and conviction rates differ across racial and ethnic groups, so a blanket policy of rejecting anyone with an arrest can screen out one group far more often than others. The EEOC guidance says that kind of policy can be illegal when the employer cannot show it is job related and consistent with business necessity. A worker can also bring a claim if an employer applies its policy differently by race or national origin.

What an Employer May Look At

  • The conduct, not the arrest

    An employer may ask about or investigate the underlying conduct if it is relevant to the position, but the decision should rest on what actually happened.

  • What the job involves

    A link between the alleged conduct and the duties, such as handling money or working with vulnerable people, carries more weight than a general worry.

  • How long ago it happened

    Older events and a record of steady work since then can weigh against an automatic rejection.

  • A chance to respond

    The guidance encourages employers to let the worker explain before a final decision, which is often when a dismissed case or mistaken record comes to light.

Background Check Reports and the Seven-Year Rule

When a background check company prepares your report, the Fair Credit Reporting Act generally bars it from including arrest records that are more than seven years old. That limit has an exception for jobs paying a high salary, so it does not protect every worker. If a report led to your firing or a lost offer, see our guide to firing after a background check for the notice and dispute steps that can apply.

State and Local Rules Can Go Further

Many states and cities limit when an employer may ask about arrests, require a written explanation before rejecting an applicant, or protect sealed and expunged records. Because these laws vary, the place where you work can change what an employer is allowed to do. If the job offer was withdrawn, our guide to a rescinded job offer covers other angles.

What To Save

  • The decision

    Keep the termination notice, withdrawn offer or message that explains the decision.

  • Court paperwork

    Save documents showing the charge was dropped, dismissed or never filed, and any record of expungement or sealing.

  • The background report

    Request a copy of the report the employer used and any notice you were sent before the decision.

  • Comparisons

    Note whether coworkers with similar records or incidents kept their jobs or were hired.

Raise It and Watch the Deadline

If the stated reason does not add up, consider asking in writing for the basis of the decision and keep a copy. The EEOC time limits are short: a charge generally must be filed within 180 days, extended to 300 days in many states. You can read more about race discrimination protections if the policy seems to fall harder on one group.

Free Case Review

If you lost a job or an offer over an arrest that did not lead to a conviction, our team can review what happened at no cost, if you are eligible.

Can an employer fire me for an arrest alone?

In most states an employer can end at-will employment for many reasons, but under EEOC guidance an arrest alone is not proof of misconduct, and a policy that relies on it can violate Title VII when it is not job related. State law may add more protection.

Can an employer ask about my arrests in an interview?

Federal law does not ban the question outright, but many states and cities do, and the EEOC discourages relying on arrests. Check the rules where you apply.

Does a dismissed charge or expungement matter?

Yes. A dismissed, dropped or sealed case is strong evidence that an arrest should not be held against you, and some states bar employers from considering sealed records.

What if the arrest relates to the job, such as a theft at work?

An employer may act on conduct that is relevant to the job when it has a real basis for believing it happened. The question is whether the decision rests on the conduct or only on the arrest.

Primary Sources

Need Legal Help?

If you're dealing with workplace rights at work, YesLawyer can review your employment-law options. Get a free consult.

Get a Free Consult With Employment Lawyers →