Workplace Rights2 min read

Vaccine Requirement at Work: Religious or Medical Exemption Requests, Undue Hardship and Your Rights

Published
Employee reading a workplace health policy notice: Vaccine Exemption at Work: Your Rights

At a glance

Vaccine Requirement at Work: Religious or Medical Exemption Requests, Undue Hardship and Your Rights: key takeaways

A visual summary of this post's main points. Read the article for context and limits.

  • Key point 1

    An employer with 15 or more employees generally must consider a sincerely held religious objection to a vaccine requirement and accommodate it unless that would cause substantial i

  • Key point 2

    A medical exemption request is handled under the ADA, which lets an employer ask for support for the condition and weigh whether an unvaccinated worker poses a direct threat

  • Key point 3

    Possible accommodations include masks, testing, remote work or a reassignment, and the employer must discuss options in good faith

Your employer says staff must be vaccinated, and you hold a religious belief against it or have a medical reason you cannot. You may fear losing your job. Federal law gives some employees a right to ask for an exemption, though the result depends on your job, your employer and your state.

In this article
  1. Religious Exemption Requests Under Title VII
  2. Medical Exemption Requests Under the ADA
  3. Accommodations an Employer May Offer
  4. Signs Your Treatment May Be Unlawful
  5. What To Save
  6. Retaliation and Deadlines
  7. Free Case Review

Key takeaways

  • An employer with 15 or more employees generally must consider a sincerely held religious objection to a vaccine requirement and accommodate it unless that would cause substantial increased costs, a higher bar after the Supreme Court's Groff decision

  • A medical exemption request is handled under the ADA, which lets an employer ask for support for the condition and weigh whether an unvaccinated worker poses a direct threat

  • Possible accommodations include masks, testing, remote work or a reassignment, and the employer must discuss options in good faith

  • An employer should not reject a religious request just because the belief is unfamiliar or the worker is not a member of a recognized church

  • Save your written request, the reply and any new discipline, because timing and how similar requests were handled are key evidence

  • An EEOC charge generally must be filed within 180 days, extended to 300 days in many states, and some states add their own protections

Religious Exemption Requests Under Title VII

The EEOC religious discrimination guidance explains that Title VII requires employers with 15 or more employees to accommodate a sincerely held religious belief unless that would cause undue hardship. After the Supreme Court's decision in Groff v. DeJoy, undue hardship means substantial increased costs in relation to the employer's business, not just a small burden. Our guide to religious accommodation firings covers the general rules, and our overview of religious discrimination at work explains what counts as a belief.

Medical Exemption Requests Under the ADA

If a medical condition keeps you from being vaccinated, the ADA treats your request as a reasonable accommodation request. The EEOC technical assistance says an employer may ask for supporting information and may consider whether an unvaccinated worker would pose a direct threat that cannot be reduced by other steps. Read our guide to the ADA interactive process and to employer medical questions.

Accommodations an Employer May Offer

  • Masks or testing

    Regular testing, a mask or distancing may protect others while you stay in your job.

  • Remote work

    If your duties can be done away from the workplace, telework may be a workable option.

  • Schedule or location change

    A shift, workspace or site that limits contact with others can sometimes meet the need.

  • Reassignment

    A vacant position that does not carry the requirement may be offered if your own job cannot be adjusted.

Signs Your Treatment May Be Unlawful

  • A flat refusal

    A denial with no discussion of masks, testing or other options.

  • Questioning your faith

    Demands that you prove membership in a church, or a rejection because your belief is not widely shared.

  • Unequal handling

    Exemptions granted to some workers but denied to you for a similar job.

  • Quick discipline

    A firing, suspension or unpaid leave soon after you made the request.

What To Save

  • Your written request

    Keep the email, form or note, with its date, and the employer's reply.

  • Policy documents

    Save the mandate, deadlines and any exemption process the company announced.

  • Comparison facts

    Note which coworkers asked for exemptions and what happened to them.

  • Pay and leave records

    Keep notices of any suspension, unpaid leave or termination, and your performance reviews.

Retaliation and Deadlines

An employer cannot punish you for asking for an accommodation or complaining about discrimination. See our guide to workplace retaliation. The EEOC time limits are short: a charge generally must be filed within 180 days, extended to 300 days in many states. Our deadline guide explains how the count works.

Free Case Review

If you were fired, suspended or denied an accommodation after asking for a vaccine exemption, our team can review what happened at no cost, if you are eligible.

Can my employer fire me for refusing a vaccine?

Sometimes, if the requirement is lawful and no reasonable accommodation is available. But an employer with 15 or more employees generally must consider religious and medical exemption requests first.

Does my religious belief have to come from an organized church?

No. A belief can be sincerely held even if it is personal or not shared by your religious group, though the employer may ask limited questions about it.

What is undue hardship?

For religious requests it means substantial increased costs in relation to the employer's business, a higher bar than a minor inconvenience. For medical requests the ADA looks at significant difficulty or expense and direct threat.

What if I work for a small company or in a government job?

Federal law may not reach a very small employer, but many states do, and public employers have extra rules. A case review can sort out which apply.

Primary Sources

Need Legal Help?

If you're dealing with workplace rights at work, YesLawyer can review your employment-law options. Get a free consult.

Get a Free Consult With Employment Lawyers →